No Decision on Costco's Sewer Line Creation Yet

The developer, with the support of about 10 homeowners in the area of Old Crompond Road who have started a petition, is proposing to create a sewer district.

The creation of sewer lines, which the developer of the proposed Costco site along Route 202 has brought up, is in the hands of county legislators after Yorktown board members recently reviewed a request asking for their support. 

Yorktown supervisor Susan Siegel said the application review was referred out to the county. County legislators would have to decide if the Peekskill Sewer District Plant, owned by the county, would have the capacity to take on the additional sewage. 

The developer of Costco, with the support of about 10 homeowners in the area of Old Crompond Road who have started a petition, is proposing to create a sewer district. The developer would pay for the installation of lines and the connections to the homeowners. 

The Costco building lines would be within the former motel on Rt. 202, official said. There is a proposal for 610 parking spaces and there would be two entrances. The motel site and another piece of property across the street (which had been planned for a temple but was never built) had been on a septic system and a few years ago an application was submitted for them to be included in a local sewer district. 

Al Capellini, the attorney for the developer, said Hunterbrook Sewage District 17 was approved by the Yorktown town board a few years ago and it includes the former motel site and the property across the street, but sewer lines were never created. The town board can then petition the county to include the local sewer district in the county's sewer district plant.

"Without the sewer infrastructure there is no Costco or anything else to be developed," he said. 

However, residents who are opposed to the Costco project cite traffic congestion and unfair competition to small business owners in the area. 

"There are many other communities in Yorktown that have been waiting as much as 30 or 40 years for sewers, is it right to streamline these homes just because they are adjacent to this building project?" said Yorktown resident Jennie Sunshine, who is also a member of a new organization called Yorktown Smart Growth, geared toward monitoring developments in the town.

She said she questions if the county's sewer district would have the capacity to take on the additional sewage from Costco and the homeowners. Siegel said there is capacity in the plant, but the county has to be certain. 

"If Costco is built in this community, while these homes would now have sewer service, they would be 'paying' for this service in other ways - hearing delivery truck noise throughout the evening, having to endure bright stadium lights well into the night, their main artery (route 202) choked with trucks and an extra 1000 or so cars per hour, and their property values will inevitably decrease," Sunshine said. 

The Costco project is still being reviewed before the Yorktown planning board, whose members are looking at the environmental studies and the draft environmental impact statement (DEIS) the developer has submitted. 

Siegel said the county would review the sewer issue while town planning board members are reviewing the DEIS. Instead of waiting for the planning board to finish their review, which could take six or seven months, they will be "dual tracking. This process would help speed up the process, which is in Costco's interest.

"I don't get the sense the planning board won't approve it," Siegel said referring to the DEIS. "It's in the right zone."

Yorktown Chamber of Commerce president Joe Visconti said he believes Costco "makes perfect sense" for Yorktown because of the proposed road condition improvements, creation of 140 permanent jobs and hundreds of new construction jobs, as well as the creation and connection to the sewer district. In addition he said the project would generate $750,000 of new tax revenue and give back to the community 1 percent of the gross sales.  

The Yorktown back in April following lawsuits, but the .

The nearly 19-acre parcel site that once housed a hotel and nursery lies about 40 feet below the Taconic State Parkway overpass on Route 202 in Yorktown.

Francis T McVetty December 26, 2011 at 08:59 PM
Jill, have you even read the article you posted. How about these words from the author? [The flood strengthened resolve in white, wealthy Yorktown to scrap the long-troubled plant and divert local sewage away from the watershed, pumping it seven miles west to a facility in multiethnic, blue-collar Peekskill.] Nice, a little racial, maybe? The whole article stinks of racially motivated solutions. It is something I certainly would not be something I would be pointing to as an example. The article was published May 1, 2005 and nothing has changed in regard to the over 1000 un-sewered in Yorktown. This is for 10 families and the Costco, NOT the 1000. We will be waiting till hell freezes over before we get sewers.
Paul Moskowitz December 27, 2011 at 02:46 AM
Not only is Peekskill to receive the sewage from Yorktown's Costco expanded sewer district, but Peekskill may also experience the traffic of Costco supply trucks going through their town to get to the Bear Mountain Parkway and Route 202..
Bill January 02, 2012 at 02:19 AM
Paul, I am sure that Peekskill residents will be happy to shop at Costco once it is open. It's not like it's being built for the exclusive use of Yorktown residents.
Carolyn DePaolo January 11, 2012 at 02:45 AM
Yorktown needs a butcher, a fish store, an old fashioned deli, not another mega store. It most certainly will affect the other supermarkets in the area. There are so many products that are discounted without having to buy 5 lbs that alot of people will go just to save a couple of bucks. And wasn't BJs supposed to bring revenue back to Yorktown? I'm pretty sure they asked for a tax abatement not long after they opened. So where was the savings from them? Don't be mistaken in thinking these huge stores are an asset. Let's support the little guys in our neighborhood.
Bill January 11, 2012 at 03:10 AM
Doesn't Turco's have full service butcher and fish? And Costco actually has excellent meat and fish, albeit in somewhat larger portions. And do we need yet another deli (which Turco's also has)? And before you say that we need another bakery, Costco's bakery is excellent.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »