.
Feedback

Community Members Outraged by Swastika on Yorktown Town Justice's Political Poster

A community member is shaken up after someone drew a swastika on his political poster.

Community members are outraged by a swastika drawn on a political poster of a town justice running for reelection this year.

Tuesday night town justice was part of a political debate event at the , when he left pamphlets and posters outside the door along with the rest of the candidate's election materials.

When he walked out the door after the debate to collect his stuff, he noticed the swastika was scribbled on the poster.

"I think it's an outrage," he said and added he was shaken up and upset. "I'm not naive and I know there are all sorts of individuals, but when it hits home, it's outrageous."

Gilbert's is a WWII medic who helped liberate concentration camps during the war, he said. His father Harry enlisted in the army with a sense of urgency, as a Jew whose parents immigrated to the U.S. from Poland.

"I have no idea where that act exists on the spectrum of what it could possibly mean," Ilan Gilbert said. "Individuals might not have known the significance -- that it's a derogatory symbol."

A report was filed with the Yorktown Police Department and the defaced poster was seized as evidence. Yorktown Police Lt. Kevin Soravilla said the only other incident he could remember of an anti-Semitic message was two or three years ago when youths had drawn a swastika on a town road. 

"Hopefully we don't have a rash of them," he said and added that the problem lies with people not being educated about how hurtful the symbol can be. 

The police department is investigating the incident and if the person(s) responsible is caught, he or she would be charged with a hate crime.

Community members who were present when the poster was discovered said they were outraged.

"It shouldn't happen in Yorktown," Lou D'Amico said. 

"Hate crimes should be prosecuted," William Primavera said. "I couldn't think of a sweeter guy who should be protected from these atrocities."

His opponent in the race Gary Raniolo also said he was outraged that someone had scribbled the swastika onto the poster and that such behavior should not be tolerated.

"It strikes a cord," Gilbert said. "I'm not sure it's something that needs to be swept under the rug."

Councilman James Martorano October 26, 2011 at 01:49 am
Lanny is a dear friend of mine and I know how much this hurt him personally. It is one of the most awful things anyone can do. I hope we catch the person responsible right away!
kate solinsky October 26, 2011 at 02:23 pm
Lanny Gilbert is my uncle and I am proud of him for bringing this to the attention of the Yorktown Police Department and the press. I sincerely hope they find the cowardly individiual responsible for this hate crime. Thank you to the Yorktown Police Department for taking this seriously and keeping him safe, and thank you to the author of this editorial piece and the Yorktown Patch for running this story.
Billy L October 26, 2011 at 03:35 pm
It probably some ignorant, trouble making teenager. They'll graffiti on anything to get noticed.
Ded Yorick October 26, 2011 at 06:01 pm
The perpetrator of this unoriginal indecency needs to be apprehended. Incidentally, the swastika has been found in societies going back thousands of years. I believe it originated in the Indus Valley. I think that Schliemann found it among the ruins of Troy as well. Oddly enough, it was used in those ancient societies as a symbol of good luck and good fortune. Unfortunately, some low-class, heathen Nazi pigs had to get hold of it and ruin it for everybody.
Francis T McVetty October 26, 2011 at 08:31 pm
Quote :"It shouldn't happen in Yorktown,", No it shouldn't happen anywhere in the USA. ArTDecoPlayLand is probably right, I hope , when he says its probably some ignorant, trouble making teenager. Maybe he couldn't join the OWS demonstrators.
Sherri L. Hughes October 27, 2011 at 02:14 am
Hate crimes are not to be trifled with nor should they be qualified as simply trouble maker behavior.
Millions perished as a result of similar laissez-faire attitudes during World War II. As residents of Yorktown we should all be outraged by the actions of this individual. It behooves our Community to be vigilant in remembering that only when we lead by example can we really expect to effect change. During these politically charged times, the art of courtesy, rational discourse and respect for the opinions of others needs to be in the forefront of our daily actions. Judge Gilbert’s selfless commitment to the judiciary should be celebrated and supported by the Yorktown Community. What a message that would send to all hate crime mongers. Sherri Hughes
Francis T McVetty October 27, 2011 at 03:13 pm
I do hope Sherri that your outrage carries on to the OWS demonstrators, for some of them have expressed the same views towards the Jews. This seems to be happening in other places in Westchester.also.
William Primavera October 27, 2011 at 05:43 pm
I was there when Ilan first discovered the defaced poster. And when he asked whether I thought he should report it, I said, of course! He MUST report it! Hate crimes will not be tolerated in Yorktown and will not go unreported.
Francis T McVetty October 27, 2011 at 06:09 pm
William, you are absolutely right.
Paladin October 28, 2011 at 01:13 am
"One of the most awful things anyone can do?" Really? Wow, so it's more serious than raping and mutilating a child? I'm glad you're not on the council of my town, with such a warped sense of proportion. What the person did was wrong, but let's stop with the melodrama.
Paladin October 28, 2011 at 01:16 am
Come now, Francis, you silly man! Are you asking for principle or consistency from liberals? What's wrong with you?!
Yorktown Tattler October 28, 2011 at 01:22 am
Palladin, I think that most people would find your comment insensitive. This is not a contest of saying what the worst crimes can be. But it was indeed one of the most awful things a person could do.
Yorktown Tattler October 28, 2011 at 01:23 am
Ah, Paladin, now I understand from your last comment, where you're coming from. How could I expect sensitivity from you?
Active Yorktowner October 28, 2011 at 01:30 am
Hi Tattler, please go over to the article about the apprehension of the suspect and my comments, and then the subsequent comments by Paladin. It amazing that we don't have more hate crime in our Town with people like him around.
C Gajowski October 28, 2011 at 03:09 pm
The act was disgusting. Why anyone would use this to attack Judge Gilbert is impossible to understand; it isn't acceptable anywhere, but is quite shocking at a town forum. The reason this is significant is that there is a need for recognition that the attitude represented by this defacement is one can be a precursor of worse crimes. I think it is also important to point out that the initial phases of antiSemitism in the 30's in Germany included scapegoating targeted groups - making it acceptable in that society to express hate and unsupported accusations against the Jews - and others - before removing their civil rights and moving into the horrors that followed. It's too bad some commentators can't express their disapproval of this act without thoughtlessly demonizing other groups.
Francis T McVetty October 28, 2011 at 06:34 pm
C Gajowski, haven't you not seen this from the OWS protesters? Some of them blame the Jews because they "control" wall street and the money supply. Sound familiar? This antisemitism is growing not only here in the USA but has been growing for years in Europe. As far as demonizing other groups, just what groups are you referring to?
C Gajowski October 28, 2011 at 10:04 pm
The Occupy Wall Street people are just that - people - of all ages, from all walks of life, with different reasons for being there, and without a single clear message. But at the center is the enormous economic changes in the US economy, which leave more and more people not simply unable to thrive, but barely able to survive. .. Anti-Semitism? Read this excerpt from a Washington Post article by Richard Cohen: "Reckless Jew that I am, I muscled my way into the Occupy Wall Street encampment in Lower Manhattan despite multiple reports of virulent and conceivably lethal anti-Semitism. Projecting an unvarnished Semitism, I circled the place, encountering nothing and no one to suggest bigotry — not a sign, not a book and not even the guy who some weeks ago held up a placard with the instruction to Google the phrase “Zionists control Wall St.” Google “nut case” instead ... The Anti-Defamation League has managed to find a paltry few. But even this watchdog Jewish organization, while noting the odd Jew-hater on the periphery of the anti-Wall Street group, found that “anti-Semitism has not gained traction . . . nor is it representative of the larger movement at this time.” Possibly more representative is the fact that Jewish religious services were held at the protest site for the holidays of Yom Kippur and Simchat Torah."
Paladin October 29, 2011 at 03:24 am
Good you get it. I couldn't care less what a bunch of immoral poseurs find insensitive. If people like you approved of me, I'd be worried. If you think that defacing a poster with a symbol associated with evil is one of the worst things that could be done in a world of genocide, mutilation, child rape and many other unspeakable crimes, you have indicted yourself.
Paladin October 29, 2011 at 03:26 am
The Washington Post is a propagandizing leftist rag that is carrying water for the OWS miscreants.
Wise up.
Paladin October 29, 2011 at 03:28 am
Actually, you are a hater and a person responsible for evil. Unlike you, I don't support discriminating against some groups by offering others special treatment. I don't say that some groups can be spoken of pejoratively while others can't.
You are a bigot and ought to be ashamed of yourself.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Yorktown-Somers Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Jarid proudly displaying his graduation diploma and "Altruistic Act of the Year" Award
Carolyn DePaolo June 18, 2013 at 08:20 pm
Jarid is an exceptionally giving person. We are so very proud of him, today and every day. WeRead More certainly can all learn a life lesson from Jarid. Love you and we are so proud of you Jarid!
Lisa Buchman (Editor) June 17, 2013 at 01:45 pm
Thanks for sharing this photo. We'd love to hear more from these groups; if you'd like to startRead More blogs on Patch, which archive your posts all together and give you a great landing page on the site, please email me at LisaB@Patch.com.
Joey Cirone June 11, 2013 at 01:45 pm
Correction: The Yorktown Leo's Club raised and is giving away $12,600 this year!!
Lisa Buchman (Editor) June 13, 2013 at 09:13 am
That is fantastic! These are really nice photos - terrific young leaders at work. If you'd like toRead More set the Leo's up with a blog, they can document their service through brief write ups or photos throughout the year. Email me LisaB@Patch.com if you are interested.