Animal Cruelty at Nature 'Preserve'

Westchester County, NY January, 2014   Animal Defenders of Westchester (ADOW) condemns the plan for Teatown Nature 'Preserve' to kill their resident deer, and  have reached out to Executive Director Kevin Carter, urging him to immediately terminate their contract with the USDA to kill deer.

On January 8, 2014 reports emerged that Teatown Lake Reservation, a non profit wildlife organization whose mission is to 'offer environmental education to adults and children', has contracted with the USDA to kill appx 75 local deer, with the usual playing-god 'invasive species' skewed science that they 'eat all the plants that would feed other species.' They quote sources such as Cornell University, which has been shown to have a profitable, nefarious, vested-interest partnership with the USDA to kill animals.  Teatown was quoted as saying they'd considered using birth control on the deer, as has been done successfully elsewhere, but instead outrageously chose killing them instead because it was 'cheaper.'   Teatown has a million-dollar budget, with a list of corporate sponsors that includes Goldman Sachs, Pepsico, the Ritz Carlton, Microsoft and Con Edison.  Of course Teatown, assisted by the scurrilous USDA, issued a 'nice' spin on the slaughter by announcing that the slaughtered animals will be 'donated to a food bank.'  Teatown lists a variety of engaging activities for the public, including a wine tasting, camping and eagle-watching; this slaughter will not be among their 'charming' list of events. 

Kiley Blackman, Founder of ADOW, said, 'This is a gross embarrassment for Teatown.  It is disgraceful that a nature 'preserve' has chosen to kill animals!  Do they understand the meaning of the word 'preserve'?  Carter knows what they're doing is unacceptable and unnecessary, and is doing a fast dance to explain it away.  We spoke on Jan 8; at that time he acknowledged that the birth control program might actually be viable but is 'waiting to see' if it works; meanwhile the USDA has convinced him to use their 'sharpshooters' for thousands of dollars, despite community complaints and the fact that other deer will take their place.  This is a massive failure and/or coverup on the part of Teatown: I asked Carter to provide data on which other species were 'suffering' as a result of the deer...and he had no response.  Taking the position that Teatown is 'helping' the deer by killing them, Carter said the deer are 'suffering and starving' - but ignored the fact that they'll also suffer when they're shot. He had no response when I suggested simply feeding the deer if they're hungry.  He did acknowledge that humans are the true 'invasive species' responsible for the urban sprawl smothering the planet and taking the animal's habitat away.  The USDA perpetrates the 'invasive species' garbage because they profit from killing animals to the tune of 125 MILLION DOLLARS per year by killing them.  ADOW is having ongoing meetings with various congresspersons with the aim of curtailing the USDA killing spree, We have forwarded information about the USDA to Mr. Carter and will continue to reach out to him.  Since Carter's position is that killing the deer will 'stop them from starving' I guess its a good thing he's not in charge of the food bank himself - the hungry poor people there would face a cruel death as well, with the excuse of 'putting them out of their misery.'  
Kiley Blackman January 10, 2014 at 07:05 PM
The wonderful deer photo is by our friend Julie Serenson. Contact us via Westchester4Geese, our adjunct on Facebook: www.Facebook.com/westchester4geese Thank you!
Toni G January 11, 2014 at 06:36 PM
" He did acknowledge that humans are the true 'invasive species' responsible for the urban sprawl smothering the planet and taking the animal's habitat away. " This? Is where you lost ANY support I might have shown for your position.
Richard Pansy January 11, 2014 at 06:41 PM
As a supporter of Teatown for nearly 30 years, I am stunned and disappointed by their decision as to how to address the deer "problem". Somehow , I fail to understand and resent the fact that my donations and fees are being used to kill rather than preserve our wildlife...I'm sure that ,morally, whatever expense , for deer "birth control" , would be approved by the many Teatown supporters . Possibly, until the birth control methods yield it's desired results, a program of ,at least minimal, food maintainence could be provided. We must realize that the deer were here long before we were, as were their natural preditors , since we have eliminated their preditors, and reduced their natural habitat, we , morally , should not assume the roll of their preditor but employ a more humane resolution to the problem that we have caused
Kiley Blackman January 12, 2014 at 06:56 PM
Richard, thank you for your wonderful, well thought-out response!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »